Herniated Disc: No Reason to Suffer

A Comprehensive Clinical Guide to Understanding Disc Herniation: What it is, Why it Happens, What Truly Causes the Pain, and How to Return to Full Function – Based on Science and Clinical Experience

Disc herniation is considered one of the most frightening and painful back issues. Many experience it as a "life-changing" event, but the clinical truth is encouraging: in the majority of cases, rapid and significant improvement can be achieved through conservative means. One can return to work, physical activity, and daily life—and prevent unnecessary recurrences—by treating the source of the problem rather than just the symptoms.

Getty Images

Important to Know: In most cases of disc herniation, controlled conservative treatment (precise manual therapy, tailored exercise, and patient education) leads to marked improvement within weeks to months, without the need for surgery.

What is a Disc Herniation?

Between every two vertebrae in the spinal column lies an intervertebral disc. The disc is composed of a fibrous outer ring (Annulus Fibrosus) containing a gelatinous center (Nucleus Pulposus). In a disc herniation, part of the nucleus penetrates through a tear in the fibrous ring, potentially creating mechanical pressure on a nearby nerve root and triggering a local inflammatory response. The combination of mechanical pressure, inflammation, and protective muscle guarding around the affected area creates the symptoms of pain.

Conceptual Accuracy: There is no "fixed percentage" of material that herniates. The extent of the herniation varies from case to case. Furthermore, MRI findings often show bulges or herniations that cause no pain at all—which is why clinical diagnosis is just as important as imaging.

Why Does It Happen? Risk Factors and Loading

A disc herniation is the result of a combination of structure, mechanical load, and lifestyle circumstances:

  • Genetics and Structure: Individual variation in the tissue's ability to tolerate mechanical stress.
  • Sedentary Lifestyle: Prolonged sitting, physical inactivity, and a decrease in muscle strength and load tolerance.
  • Repetitive or Sudden Loading: Lifting heavy loads, sharp rotational/flexion movements, and demanding physical labor.
  • Smoking and Poor Nutrition: Factors linked to degenerative changes in the disc and a reduced capacity for tissue healing.
  • Stress: Increases muscle tone, lowers pain tolerance, and reinforces protective "guarding" patterns.
  • Movement Compensations: Restrictions in adjacent joints (hip, ankle, or thoracic spine) that force the lumbar region to overwork and compensate.

When and How is the Pain Created?

The pain does not result solely from a "disc pressing on a nerve." The inflammatory response and the muscles that stiffen around the area to "protect" it play a crucial role. This leads to movement restriction, circumferential pressure on the nerve, and often radiation into the leg (Sciatica).

Typical Symptoms:

  • Sharp or burning pain in the lower back.
  • Radiation of pain into the leg.
  • Tingling or numbness (paresthesia).
  • A sensation of heaviness or weakness in the limb.
  • Difficulty with prolonged standing or sitting.

Red Flags: When to Seek Urgent Medical Attention

While most cases of disc herniation can be managed conservatively, certain symptoms require immediate medical evaluation to prevent permanent neurological damage:

  • Progressive Neurological Deficit: Increasing weakness in the leg or foot (Foot Drop) or extensive loss of sensation.

  • Saddle Anesthesia and Sphincter Dysfunction: Loss of sensation in the "saddle area" (perineum/groin) or loss of bladder/bowel control.

  • Constitutional Symptoms: Back pain accompanied by fever, chills, or unexplained rapid weight loss.

  • Medical History and Trauma: Significant physical trauma, or a history of active oncological conditions.

What Can Be Done? Conservative Treatment Approaches

High-quality conservative treatment combines pain reduction with the restoration of load tolerance and normal movement. The primary components include:

  • Precise Manual Therapy: Reducing protective muscle guarding, releasing tissues (fascia and trigger points), and improving joint mobility.
  • Tailored Exercise: Improving lumbar control, optimizing breathing and intra-abdominal pressure, strengthening the hips and gluteal muscles, and developing dynamic posture.
  • Education and Load Management: Graded return to activity, establishing a "daily movement dose," and ergonomic adjustments.
  • Supportive Measures (as needed): Pain and anti-inflammatory medication, heat/cold therapy, or TENS—utilized as short-term aids to facilitate movement.

What the Research Says: In the vast majority of disc herniation cases, tailored conservative treatment is preferred as the first line of defense. A high percentage of patients show significant improvement within weeks to months without the need for surgical intervention.

Precise Manual Therapy: Principles and Application

Manual therapy is aimed at reducing the load surrounding the nerve, decreasing the hyperactivity of protective muscles, and improving mobility in adjacent joints. It includes:

  • Trigger Point and Fascial Release: To reduce tension and achieve peripheral pain inhibition.
  • Joint Mobilizations: Gentle movement to improve neural gliding and local segmental mobility.
  • HVLA (When Appropriate): To release segmental restrictions, applied through informed and safe clinical decision-making.

The Winning Combination: Manual Therapy + Active Exercise → leads to superior outcomes compared to exercise alone, thanks to its impact on both pain mechanisms and movement patterns.

Active Rehabilitation: Breathing, Control, and Progression

Guiding Principles:

  • Lumbar Control: Re-learning a neutral lumbar spine position and developing dynamic stability during flexion, extension, and rotation—implemented gradually and guided by pain symptoms.
  • Breathing and Intra-Abdominal Pressure (IAP): Utilizing the diaphragm and pelvic floor to support loading. Synchronized breathing reduces muscle "guarding" and facilitates neural gliding.
  • Gluteal and Hip Function: Eccentric and concentric strengthening, mastering the "Hip-Hinge" pattern, and shifting mechanical load away from the lumbar spine to improve gait and stair climbing.
  • Load Progression: Implementing a graded dosage based on the Rate of Perceived Exertion (RPE); gradually increasing load, range, and speed while monitoring the patient's response 24–48 hours post-training.

Surgery: When to Proceed, When to Avoid, and What the Research Says

Surgery (such as a discectomy) may be an option in specific, well-defined cases: progressive neurological deficit, neurosurgical emergencies (such as sphincter dysfunction), or pain that remains exceptionally resistant after a sufficient period of high-quality conservative care.

Numerous studies indicate that in the long term, the clinical outcomes of surgery and conservative treatment tend to converge. The primary advantage of surgery is often seen in the reduction of suffering duration in carefully selected cases.

The Bottom Line: In the vast majority of cases, high-quality conservative treatment is the starting point. Surgery is considered only when "Red Flags" are present or when there is no significant progress after a reasonable timeframe under a tailored treatment plan.

Prevention and Safe Return to Activity

  • Daily Movement Dose: Consistent walking, gentle mobility, and short daily exercise sessions are far superior to "compensating" with a single intense workout once a week.
  • Load Hygiene: Progressive work loading, taking short breaks during sedentary work, and implementing simple ergonomic adjustments.
  • Breathing and Stress Management: Utilizing breathing and relaxation protocols to reduce excessive muscle tone and sympathetic nervous system arousal.
  • Functional Strengthening: Emphasizing gluteal activation, the "Hip-Hinge" pattern, and lumbar control to restore movement confidence and structural resilience.
  • Education: Understanding the mechanism of the injury, identifying specific pain triggers, and learning how to intercept symptoms early. This knowledge creates a lasting impact that resonates for years to come.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Is an MRI Necessary? Not always. Diagnosis is primarily clinical. An MRI is typically considered only when "Red Flags" are present, there is a lack of progress in conservative treatment, or if invasive interventions are being contemplated.

 

Do I Have to Stop Exercising? Generally, no. We perform a temporary adjustment of load, range of motion, and specific movement patterns, and then gradually return to activity while closely monitoring the body's response.

 

How Soon Will I Feel Improvement? This varies from person to person. However, many patients experience significant pain reduction and improved function within the first few weeks of targeted conservative treatment.

 

You Can Return to a Full Life

With the help of precise diagnosis, targeted manual therapy, and active rehabilitation, the vast majority of those suffering from a disc herniation return to work, physical activity, and a full life. You don’t have to suffer—you just need the right plan.

Article Author: Giveon Peled Founder of the STB Method and Pain Management Specialist.

Want to understand the exact source of your pain and learn how to stop it?

Join the STB Manual Therapy Course
Back to All Articles

Recommended Research and Literature

Chou R, et al. Nonoperative Treatments for Low Back Pain. Ann Intern Med, 2016.

Peul WC, et al. Surgical vs Conservative Management for Lumbar Disc Herniation. NEJM, 2007.

Vroomen PC, et al. Conservative Treatment of Sciatica: Systematic Review. Spine, 2000.

Rubinstein SM, et al. Spinal Manipulative Therapy for Low-Back Pain. Cochrane Review, 2019.

McGill SM. Low Back Disorders: Evidence-based Prevention and Rehabilitation. Human Kinetics, 2015.

Sahrmann SA. Movement System Impairment Syndromes. Mosby, 2002.